Advanced Search +

Fastest Method for Field Scoring White-tailed Deer (video)

Posted by 
August 28, 2014
Published in News & Tips > Hunting > Deer
32010   Comment

You hear hooves in the leaves. Where is he? There! There he is! A buck is ghosting in. Is he the one in the trail camera photos? Is he big enough to book? Does he meet the management standards for this property? Is the antler score enough for the outfitter with whom you are hunting? Lots of questions, and you better answer them fast because he's steadily marching toward your narrow shooting window.

If you're a hunter who's serious about putting a deer in the record book, part of your training must be to learn exactly what net 125-inch bucks and 170-inch bucks look like. As "Mr. Whitetail" Larry Weishuhn suggests, you may have even made flashcards from photos of mounted heads to memorize the size of various racks. But most of us are just trying to make sure we don't offend a host on whose property we're hunting or incur a "penalty" fee for shooting a buck smaller than the minimum.

1 arrow pointTIP: How to Quickly Score White-Tailed Deer - LINK


Often, when a buck's in view, you have only seconds to make your assessment of its antlers. You need a system that's fast. Here's the fastest.

1 arrow pointTIP: Before hunting, ask your host or outfitter what the average "frame size" is for mature bucks in that area. If they are practicing quality deer management, they'll know. What you're looking for is a base number encompassing the length and mass of main beams and the average spread.


FastestMethodFieldScoringWhitetailDeer 1


Weishuhn says, if you're hunting unmanaged property but still want to use this method, consider average body size of mature bucks in that region. If bucks of 4 1/2 to 6 1/2 years range around the 200-pound mark, then assume a base frame of 90 inches. If the adult bucks are in the 125- to 150-pound range, use a base of 80. If you're in prairie Canada where bucks can legitimately weigh 300 pounds, then frame base may be as high as 100. With that knowledge all you need to do is add the length of each antler tine to the base to provide a good estimate of gross antler score.

The key is knowing you're looking at a "mature" buck. Aging deer on the hoof is another important management skill in itself, but when it comes to antler size, it's often a "you'll know it when you see it" proposition. Immature bucks usually wear thin horns and basket racks. On the other end, when a buck is in the 160s and up, your biggest challenge will be screwing your eyeballs back into their sockets to take the shot!

Hunt the Trail Less-Traveled for Mature Bucks - video


The Base Frame System for Quick Scoring of Whitetail Deer

The tough ones are in the middle at 130-150 inches, and this is where the base frame system is worth knowing. Say you're hunting western Kentucky along the Ohio River. This is a region, just like Illinois on the river's western bank, known for big deer. Bucks of 200 pounds aren't uncommon, so the frame base number is 90. A buck shows up in front of your stand. He's an 8-point, but from his filled out neck and brisket, slightly swayed back, blunted nose, and swagger you can tell he's at least four and maybe five.

Start adding.
Right brow tine 4 inches.
Left brow tine 6 inches.
Right G2 is 10.
Left G2 is 11.
Right G3 is 6.
Left G3 is 8.
Total gross score 135 inches. Nice buck! But he's 5 inches shy of the 140-inch minimum for the property on which you're hunting. Let him walk.

For this graphic to quickly score white-tailed deer, A = tines, B = Tines and C = Tines. Beam Length is the measurement from the bottom of the burr to the tip of main beam.



To judge tine length, you need perspective. The whitetail's ear is 6 1/2 inches long. The eye is 2 inches from preorbital gland to the back of the socket. From the front of the antler base to the tip of the nose is about 10 inches.

1 arrow pointAnd one more tip...all of this analysis is best done as "close up" as possible with good binoculars or even a spotting scope. The magnification of quality optics allows analysis at a distance so you can make your shoot/no shoot decision well before the buck's in range.

* Books and videos are available on how to estimate deer scores and age animals through the Quality Deer Management Association. Also visit taxidermy shops and rough score deer on display in your head. Then find out what the animal actually scored and see how close you were



Tagged under Read 32010 times Last modified on November 27, 2018
Bill Miller

Since age 11, Bill Miller knew he wanted to experience outdoor adventures and share them with others. He wanted to be an outdoor writer. In the decades since, he has lived and continues living his dream.

His first job out of school with North American Hunter magazine lasted 28 years and included roles as editor, author, TV host and producer, scriptwriter, spokesperson, editorial and content strategist, executive, hunting and firearms blogger, and probably best known as Executive Director of the 900,000-member North American Hunting Club. Today, Bill continues many of these pursuits in his own enterprise, Bill Miller Outdoors.

He travels widely enjoying adventures back home in Wisconsin and Minnesota as well as on five continents. He shared his adventures on national networks hosing and producing shows for NBC Sports, Versus, Outdoor Channel, Wild TV, Sportsman Channel and others. He appeared on ESPN for 13 season on "Shoot More, Shoot More Often."

Bill is a cornerstone member of the Professional Outdoor Media Association serving as a director, past president and chairman. He also sits on the board of directors of the Hunting Heritage Trust.

In 2012, Bill joined Bass Pro Shops pro staffer Brenda Valentine on the Armed Forces Entertainment Outdoor Legends Tour to Afghanistan to entertain mena and women serving in the military -- in his words, " was the greatest honor in my career and a life changing experience.

His latest venture is a new book, "Reflections Under the Big Pine" he co-authored and published with K.J. Houtman.


Latest from Bill Miller


You must be signed in to post comments on Bass Pro Shops 1Source. Don't have an account? Please join Bass Pro Shops 1Source.
  • No comments found